Welcome to CPA at Law, helping individuals and small businesses plan for the future and keep what they have.

This is the personal blog of Sterling Olander, a Certified Public Accountant and Utah-licensed attorney. For over thirteen years, I have assisted clients with estate planning and administration, tax mitigation, tax controversies, small business planning, asset protection, and nonprofit law.

I write about any legal, tax, or technological information that I find interesting or useful in serving my clients. All ideas expressed herein are my own and don't constitute legal or tax advice.

Basics of Foreign Income Taxation

From a U.S. perspective, personal income taxation is based on (1) citizenship, (2) residency, and (3) income source. U.S. citizens are taxed on U.S. source and foreign source income, regardless of residence. Non-citizen residents (those who possess a green card or who were present in the U.S. 31 days during the current year and 183 days over the last three years) are taxed the same as U.S. citizens. Non-citizen, non-residents are usually taxed only on U.S. source income.

Different applications of these basic principles apply to the U.S. territories. For example, U.S. citizens residing in Puerto Rico are taxed similar to non-citizen, non-residents even though Puerto Rico is a U.S. territory: only U.S. source income is taxed by the U.S. In contrast, U.S. citizens residing in American Samoa are taxed on worldwide income but can exclude American Samoa source income; each territory is different.

Those who are taxed on worldwide income by the U.S. and who also have foreign source income and pay taxes to foreign countries may be able to (1) exclude foreign source income from reported U.S. gross income, (2) deduct foreign taxes paid from U.S. gross income, or (3) receive a credit against U.S. taxes for foreign taxes paid. These rules are intended to prevent the same income from being fully taxed by two different countries.

For those not taxed on worldwide income, properly determining the source of income for tax purposes is critical. In general, the U.S. considers personal service income to be sourced from where the services are performed. Interest income is sourced to the payer of the interest. Dividend income is U.S. source if paid by a U.S. corporation and foreign source if paid by a foreign corporation (but different rules apply where a foreign corporation is generating income "effectively connected" to the U.S.) With some exceptions, rents and royalties are sourced to the location of the property generating the income. Income from the sale of personal property is sourced to the seller's location, with special rules for inventory and intangibles. Gains from the sale of real estate is sourced to the location of the real property.

This is a broad overview of general principles that apply to U.S. worldwide income taxation. Other issues that could arise include tax withholding on U.S. source income of foreign persons, tax treaties between the U.S. and foreign countries, and foreign account reporting requirements, to name a few. It is never a bad idea to engage local counsel when dealing with foreign income and tax reporting.

Foreign Account Reporting Requirements

The U.S. reporting requirements for individuals with foreign assets are complex. This post will focus on the reporting requirements for a citizen and resident of the U.S. with a foreign financial account. The starting point for these requirements will be Schedule B, Interest and Dividends, for Form 1040, U.S. Individual Income Tax Return.

Part III of Schedule B, Question 7, asks whether the taxpayer had, in the past year, "a financial interest in or signature authority over a financial account... located in a foreign country." The question also asks whether the taxpayer is required to file FinCEN Form 114, Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) to report that interest or authority. The FBAR is a different form, independent of Schedule B or Form 1040 in general, but with nearly identical definitions and requirements. In fact the instructions to Schedule B direct the taxpayer to refer to the FBAR for additional information. If the answer to Question 7 is "yes," the taxpayer should plan on filing an FBAR as well.

A U.S. person must file an FBAR by June 30 of the following year if the aggregate value of the foreign financial accounts in which the person has a financial interest or or over which the person has signature authority exceeds $10,000 at any time during the reporting year. A U.S. person who is the owner of record or holder of legal title, or is able to control the owner of record or holder of legal title, of a foreign financial account meets the definition of having a "financial interest." Signature authority is defined as the authority (alone or in conjunction with another) to control the disposition of assets held in the account by communicating to the institution that maintains the account.

Depending on how the foreign asset came to be owned by the taxpayer, Form 3520, Annual Return To Report Transactions With Foreign Trusts and Receipt of Certain Foreign Gifts may be required. This form is referenced in Question 8, Part III of Schedule B to Form 1040, which asks whether the taxpayer received a distribution from, was the grantor of, or was the transferor to, a foreign trust. U.S. persons who, among other things, received either (1) a gift or bequest of more than $100,000 from a nonresident alien individual or a foreign estate or (2) a gift of more than $15,102 from a foreign entity, must file Form 3520.

Another potentially required form is Form 8938, Statement of Specified Foreign Financial Assets, which accompanies the personal income tax return. The requirements for this form are similar to the requirements for an FBAR; in fact, the IRS has published a Comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR Requirements. In short, Form 8938 is required when a U.S. person has a foreign financial asset, including a foreign financial account, worth more than an applicable threshold, which thresholds are summarized on page 2 of the instructions.

While this discussion has focused on the reporting requirements applicable to foreign financial accounts, the following instructions for Form 8938 are instructive in providing an idea of what is required when dealing with other kinds of assets:

"You do not have to report any asset on Form 8938 if you report it on one or more of the following forms that you timely file with the IRS for the same tax year.
  • Form 3520, Annual Return To Report Transactions With Foreign Trusts and Receipt of Certain Foreign Gifts.
  • Form 5471, Information Return of U.S. Persons With Respect To Certain Foreign Corporations.
  • Form 8621, Information Return by a Shareholder of a Passive Foreign Investment Company or Qualified Electing Fund.
  • Form 8865, Return of U.S. Persons With Respect to Certain Foreign Partnerships.
  • Form 8891, U.S. Information Return for Beneficiaries of Certain Canadian Registered Retirement Plans."

Source: Carolyn Reers, U.S. Tax Compliance for U.S. Persons With Interests in Foreign Accounts, Trusts, Corporations and Partnerships, ST008 ALI-ABA, September 2011.

Unrelated Business Income Tax

Certain organizations are exempt from paying income tax under the Internal Revenue Code. These include charitable, religious, and scientific organizations; certain pension, profit sharing, and stock bonus plans; IRAs; colleges and universities; and medical savings and college savings accounts. To the extent that these organizations generate "exempt function income," such as "income from dues, fees, charges, or similar items paid by members for the purposes for which exempt status was granted," such income is not subject to federal income tax.

For exempt organizations, income that meets certain characteristics is not exempt function income and is instead unrelated business taxable income on which tax must be paid. Activities that (1) constitute a trade or business, (2) are regularly carried on, and (3) are not substantially related to furthering the exempt purpose of the organization generate unrelated business taxable income.

A "trade or business" is defined as "any activity carried on for the production of income from selling goods or performing services." To be "regularly carried on," the activities would "show a frequency and continuity, and [be] pursued in a manner similar to, comparable commercial activities of nonexempt organizations." Finally, for an activity to be "not substantially related" to the exempt purpose, the activity would lack a "[substantial] causal relationship to achieving exempt purposes (other than through the production of income)."

The specific rules regarding UBIT are numerous, with certain types of income being subject to UBIT depending on the type of exempt organization that generates the income or the intended purpose of the income. Deductions directly connected with producing the unrelated income are generally deductible in a similar manner as regular business deductions, although certain types of deductions are disallowed. Conceptually, the purpose behind the UBIT rules is to prevent normal for-profit businesses from experiencing unfair competition from an exempt organization engaging in the exact same activity without having to pay the tax that the for-profit business pays.

Avoid Owning Real Estate in a Corp

Tony Nitti, writing for Forbes, wrote a great article earlier this year that clearly explains Why You Should Never Hold Real Estate In A Corporation. Following is a summary of the primary reasons, contrasted with owning real estate in a partnership:

Capital Contributions: If an individual transfers real property to a corporation in exchange for stock, they must own 80% of the vote and value of the corporation immediately after the transfer; otherwise, a gain must be recognized and tax paid on the difference between the individual's basis in the property and the fair market value. In contrast, "appreciated property can be contributed to a partnership in exchange for a partnership interest [as small as a 1%] without triggering any gain."

Contributions of Property Subject to a Mortgage: Even if a contribution of real property to a corporation is otherwise exempt from gain, if the property is subject to a mortgage, "and the corporation assumes that liability as part of the transfer, the transfer triggers gain to the extent the liability exceeds the tax basis of the property." In contrast, it is "much less likely that a partner contributing leveraged property to a partnership will recognize gain" due to the inside and outside basis rules of partnership taxation.

Sale or Distribution: While it is possible to contribute real property to a corporation without being required to pay tax, the same is not true for getting the property out. If appreciated property is distributed from a corporation, "the corporation recognizes gain as if it had sold the property for its fair market value." The same treatment applies if the property is actually sold by the corporation. Furthermore, withdrawing the sales proceeds from a C-Corporation can result in double taxation to the shareholder. In the case of a distribution from an S-Corp, "the distribution will not be taxed a second time at the shareholder level..., [however the shareholder] cannot take the property out of the corporation without incurring a tax bill." In contrast, "when a partnership distributes property to a partner in a current distribution, generally no gain or loss is recognized by either the partnership or the partner;" only basis adjustments are required.

In addition to the problems listed above, owning real estate within a taxable entity other than a partnership can result in loss limitations, lost step-up in basis of the underlying assets upon the death of a shareholder, and lost step-up in basis for the purchaser of an interest in a corporation owning appreciated assets. It is almost always better to own real estate in a partnership or disregarded entity.

Home Office Deduction Safe Harbor

In addition to being a rumored audit risk, the deduction for a home office has been relatively complex, both the deduction calculation itself as well as its effect on other parts of Form 1040. For example, under the regular home office deduction method, actual expenses such as rent, real estate taxes, internet, gas and electric, phone, insurance, and other costs attributable to the square footage of the home office space must be calculated and detailed records maintained. Furthermore, home-related itemized deductions must be apportioned between Schedule A and Schedule C. Finally, while depreciation can be deducted for the portion of the home used for business, that depreciation must be recaptured upon the sale of the home.

In Revenue Procedure 2013-13, the IRS has provided an easier option. Using the "simplified" or "safe harbor" home office deduction method, a business owner can take a standard $5 deduction for each square foot of the home used exclusively for business, up to 300 square feet. There is no need to apportion house expenses to the office space, and all home-related itemized deductions may be claimed in full on Schedule A.

There is no home depreciation deduction or later recapture of depreciation for the years the simplified option is used. While deduction amounts in excess of gross income may not be carried forward as in the regular method, preparing Form 8829 is not required when electing the simplified method; calculated expenses are simply entered on Line 30 of Schedule C.

The criteria for who can take the regular or simplified home office deduction is the same: The room or section of the home used for business must be exclusively used on a regular basis (1) as a place of business used by patients, clients, or customers; (2) in connection with the trade or business if it is a separate structure unattached to the home; or (3) as the principal place of business. A home office will qualify as a principal place of business if it is used exclusively and regularly for administrative or management activities of the trade or business and no other fixed location for conducting substantial administrative or management activities of the business exists.

The IRS is strict about the exclusivity requirement. If the home office doubles as a guest bedroom, for example, the taxpayer does not qualify to take the deduction. However, the home office can be a section of a room if clearly partitioned from the rest of the room and personal activities are excluded from the business section.

While the extra complexity of the regular home office deduction method may be worth it for large home offices with high expenses, the simplified method is a good option for many other business owners who work out of their house.

Income Shifting to Children

A fundamental tax-mitigation technique is shifting income from taxpayers in high tax brackets to taxpayers in lower brackets. One of the ways this can be accomplished for business owners is by paying their children a salary for working for the business. Not only does this shift taxable income from the parent's higher-bracket to the children's lower-bracket while keeping everything within the family, this technique can also save payroll taxes compared to hiring non-family employees.

According to the IRS, "[p]ayments for the services of a child under age 18 who works for his or her parent in a trade or business are not subject to social security and Medicare taxes if the trade or business is a sole proprietorship or a partnership in which each partner is a parent of the child." Furthermore, children claimed as dependents on a parent's return and who make less than $6,200 for 2014 do not owe any income tax and are not required to file a tax return, although filing would be necessary in order to receive a refund of income tax withheld.

A parent can also match the child's wages up to $5,500 with a Roth IRA contribution in the child's name. This will reduce the parents' future tax on investment income by the amount of the return on the contribution, which would grow tax-free.

In addition to passing income in the form of "active" wages to children, "passive" income can also be passed to children. In order to take advantage of this opportunity, the "kiddie tax" must be avoided. If the tax applies, the income is taxed at the parent's highest rate instead of the child's, completely negating the strategy. However, parents can still transfer income-generating assets to children, and if the income for the tax year is under $2,000 in 2014, the child's lower rate applies. As children reach the age of majority and continue earning substantially less than their parents, the opportunities to shift passive income increases.

Gay Marriage Cases Yield Estate Tax Planning Opportunities

Some of the court decisions on the issue of gay marriage are creating estate tax loopholes that could allow wealthy individuals to pass their estate to their heirs tax free. Every state restricts close relatives from marrying. However, the language of some states' statutes technically only prohibits opposite-sex relatives from marrying, but with a definition of "marriage" that only includes male-female unions.

Consider the statute in Massachusetts, which contains the traditional definition of marriage and provides that "No man shall marry his mother, grandmother, daughter, granddaughter, sister, stepmother, grandfather’s wife, grandson’s wife, wife’s mother, wife’s grandmother, wife’s daughter, wife’s granddaughter, brother’s daughter, sister’s daughter, father’s sister or mother’s sister." There are corresponding provisions for women.

In Goodridge v. Department of Public Health, the court acknowledged this language and said in a footnote that "the statutory provisions concerning consanguinity or polygamous marriages shall be construed in a gender neutral manner." However, the statute has not been updated despite ample opportunity for the legislature to do so. Given this, it is at least arguable that, as Phillip Greenspun pointed out, a "grandfather [could] marry his grandson, give his spouse/grandson a tax-free spousal gift of $25 million, and then get a no-fault divorce after a couple of years."

In contrast, the Connecticut legislature did amend the gender-based consanguinity provisions in its marriage statutes. Shortly after the case of Kerrigan v. Commissioner of Public Health was handed down, the legislature passed Public Act No. 09-13. This act replaced the language "No man may marry his mother, grandmother, daughter, granddaughter, sister, aunt, niece, stepmother or stepdaughter, and no woman may marry her father, grandfather, son, grandson, brother, uncle, nephew, stepfather or stepson" with the following: "No person may marry such person's parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, sibling, parent's sibling, sibling's child, stepparent or stepchild."

It is unclear what rationale Connecticut or any state would have in removing the right of same-sex relatives to marry. As has been astutely pointed out, "[T]he biological rationale for the consanguinity rules makes no sense in the context of two women or two men, as there simply can be no progeny produced between them, and hence there is no possibility of in-breeding."

The state of Iowa chose to remain silent on this question; its statute declares as void any marriage between "a man and his father's sister, mother's sister, daughter, sister, son's daughter, daughter's daughter, brother's daughter, or sister's daughter" (and vice versa) in Iowa Code Ann. § 595.19. The court in Varnum v. Brien did not mention 595.19 or consanguinity and the legislature has not updated the statute since. As such, Iowa has seen fit to allow close same-sex relatives to marry; accordingly, an unmarried woman can marry her daughter and pass wealth to her tax free.

With the 10th Circuit currently considering whether to overturn traditional marriage laws in multiple states, it will be interesting to see how or if it approaches the varied consanguinity provisions within its jurisdiction. Oklahoma is poised to become another state with an estate-tax loophole.