Welcome to CPA at Law, helping individuals and small businesses plan for the future and keep what they have.

This is the personal blog of Sterling Olander, a Certified Public Accountant and Utah-licensed attorney. For over thirteen years, I have assisted clients with estate planning and administration, tax mitigation, tax controversies, small business planning, asset protection, and nonprofit law.

I write about any legal, tax, or technological information that I find interesting or useful in serving my clients. All ideas expressed herein are my own and don't constitute legal or tax advice.

Utah Uniform Electronic Estate Planning Documents Act

As I discussed in a prior post, Utah was an early adopter of an electronic Wills act, and testamentary instruments electronically executed pursuant to that act are still allowed. In addition, pursuant to the Uniform Electronic Estate Planning Documents Act ("UEEPDA"), any "electronic non-testamentary estate planning document created, signed, generated, sent, communicated, received, or stored before, on, or after May 6, 2026" pursuant to the requirements of UEEPDA is also valid.

A non-testamentary estate planning document covered by UEEPDA expressly includes all standard estate planning documents other than a Will, deed, or vehicle title. Any requirement that a document be in "writing" is satisfied if the document is in an electronic record "inscribed on a tangible medium" or "stored in an electronic or other medium and retrievable in perceivable form." This assumes that the record is "readable as text at the time of signing." As with electronic Wills, a video or audio recording of the testator's wishes does not qualify under UEEPDA because it would not be readable as text.

A non-testamentary estate planning document must still be signed by the person, but under UEEPDA, "signing" includes executing or adopting a tangible symbol or logically associating with the record an electronic signature. UEEPDA is intended to be interpreted "consistent with reasonable practices concerning electronic documents and signatures and continued expansion of those practices." UEEPDA confirms electronic notarizations as well, which have been permitted in Utah since 2019 pursuant to H.B. 52, Remote Notarization Standards.

Electronic presence is sufficient for any document required to be witnessed. Under UEEPDA, "electronic presence" is defined to mean that "two or more individuals in different locations are able to communicate in real time to the same extent as if the individuals were physically present in the same location." No document is required to be signed electronically, even if prior documents were created or signed electronically. Electronically-signed documents will not be free from contests or other estate controversy, but there does not appear to be a fundamental reason why testamentary or non-testamentary documents cannot be executed electronically when so many aspects of our lives are already digital.

Stepparent Inheritance Rights Under Utah Law

In Utah, as in every state, a surviving spouse has certain inheritance rights in the assets of their deceased husband or wife. Unless these rights are expressly waived, they exist even if the decedent attempted or intended to leave their entire estate to their children or other heirs. Since the issue of spousal inheritance rights often arises when the surviving children are not also the children of the surviving spouse, this discussion will assume that the relationship of the surviving spouse and decedent's children is that of stepparent and stepchildren.

Any part of a decedent's estate not effectively disposed of by will, trust, right of survivorship, beneficiary designation, etc. is considered part of their "intestate estate" and passes by the law of intestate succession. While the term "intestate estate” is not expressly defined in the Utah Uniform Probate Code, the simple fact that Part 1 of Title 75 of the Code determines who receives a decedent's assets can only mean that "intestate estate" refers to a decedent's assets that remain after all will, trust, and nonprobate transfers are effectuated.

"The intestate share of a decedent's surviving spouse is... the first $75,000, plus 1/2 of any balance of the intestate estate, if one or more of the decedent's surviving descendants are not descendants of the surviving spouse." Utah Code 75-2-102(1)(b). This seems simple enough, but it is relatively uncommon for all or even most of a decedent's assets to actually become part of their intestate estate. In all likelihood, most if not all, of a decedent's assets will be governed by a last will or will pass pursuant to the terms of a trust agreement, right of survivorship, or beneficiary designation. The two questions that often naturally arise are: What if the surviving spouse receives more than their statutory share of the intestate estate, and what if the surviving spouse is left very little?

One of the more confusing sections of the Utah Uniform Probate Code is the following: "For purposes of [75-2-102(1)(b)], if the intestate estate passes to both the decedent's surviving spouse and to other heirs, then any nonprobate transfer, as defined in Section 75-2-206, received by the surviving spouse is added to the probate estate in calculating the intestate heirs' shares and is conclusively treated as an advancement under Section 75-2-109 in determining the spouse's share." Utah Code 75-2-102(2). One of the confusing aspects of this section is that it borrows definitions and concepts from the "Elective Share of Surviving Spouse" statute, discussed below, even though the elective share is an entirely distinct concept from the intestate share of a surviving spouse. The reference to "advancements" adds to the confusion.

In plainer terms, Utah Code 75-2-102(2) is saying that if the remainder of a decedent's assets after the effectuation of rights of survivorship, beneficiary designations, etc. is greater than $75,000 (since that amount all passes to the surviving spouse anyway), and if a surviving spouse has already received assets from the decedent by virtue of being a surviving joint tenant, designated beneficiary, etc., then the surviving spouse's share of the intestate estate can be reduced, but without any requirement to refund assets already received, thereby increasing the intestate share of the decedent's other heirs such as stepchildren. The recalculation of the heirs' shares is done by adding up a theoretical "hotchpot" estate that includes "advancement" assets already received by the surviving spouse, as I explained in more detail in a prior post. Accordingly, in answer to the first question posed above, a surviving spouse can retain more more than their intestate share.

As for the second question posed above, the "elective share" is available to a surviving spouse who has not waived the right via a premarital agreement and who ends up left with very little, whether that is due to being expressly disinherited by a will or trust or due to stepchildren or other heirs being granted right of survivorship, designated as beneficiaries of accounts, etc. While the calculation and effectuation of the elective share can be complex, the key point is that a surviving spouse has the right "to take an elective-share amount equal to the value of 1/3 of the augmented estate." Utah Code 75-2-202(1). For maximum protection, a petition for an elective share must be filed within the earlier of nine months after the date of the decedent's death or six months after the probate of the decedent's will. See Utah Code 75-2-211(1). This is a very high-level introduction to stepparent inheritance rights and illustrates why competent legal counsel if critical in preserving these rights.

Estate Planning Without an Attorney

There are many software options that assist with the creation of an estate plan. Trust & Will is one such service, but there are many others. These products service an important need and are sufficient for the intended purposes but of course are not for everyone and cannot appropriatly address every situation. The following is a non-exhaustive list of situations that an app-generated estate plan is unlikely to be able to appropriately address:
  • Naming co-fiduciaries and defining how co-fiduciaries can act
  • Terms and conditions required by a professional fiduciary
  • Estate tax mitigation or any irrevocable trust planning
  • Supplemental needs trust provisions and planning for a disabled beneficiary
  • Protective, lifetime trusts for beneficiaries
  • Disinheritance of a natural heir or spouse
  • Income tax planning
  • Maintaining separateness of assets in a mixed family
  • Ensuring proper execution of the documents
  • Ensuring proper trust funding and updating of beneficiary designations
  • Updating an estate plan after a recent divorce
  • Asset protection planning
  • Medicaid planning
  • Restatements or amendments of existing trusts
  • Exercising powers of appointment
  • Closely-held business succession planning
  • Allowing a spouse or other current beneficiary limited use of trust assets in favor of a future beneficiary
  • Dealing with beneficiaries unable to manage money, addicted to drugs, etc.
  • Premarital or postnuptial agreements
If any of the preceeding situations apply, it will likely be well worth the cost of retaining a reputable estate planning attorney to assist with your estate plan.

Unauthorized Filings with Utah Division of Corporations

The Utah Division of Corporations is a good-faith filing office, which essentially means that almost anyone with a Utah-ID account who logs onto the Division's Business Registration System can file any document with any entity, including a Statement of Dissolution. Unauthorized filings can be reported but not undone, and depending on the filing type, an unauthorized filing may not be able to be reversed. For example, if a dissolution was filed more than 120 days previously, the opportunity to file a Revocation of Dissolution is lost. This could potentially have real-world tax impacts, interruptions to banking services, etc.

The Division's process for preventing unauthorized online filings is by associating an entity with an online account. By default, the online account responsible for forming new entities is the only account authorized to submit online filings with respect to that entity. Entities formed prior to the new Business Registration System rollout in late 2024 can be associated with an online account by request of the account user. The account user can request authority from either another account holder or, if no other account is associated with the entity, directly from the Division by filling out an Affidavit to Request Entity Authority, which must be notarized.

After emailing the Affidavit to Request Entity Authority to the Division, the Division will reply with an Invitation for Filing Authority that contains an authorization code. The designated user can enter that code in the Manage Entities and Authority section of their account, after which the entity will be added to the user's list of authorized businesses. Businesses formed prior to the new Business Registration System should take these steps in order to prevent unauthorized filings.

Trust Decanting Now Authorized by Statute in Utah

Pursuant to S.B. 206 (2025) - Estate Planning Amendments, Utah became the thirty-seventh state to statutorily authorize decanting a trust. Decant means “[t]o distribute (the assets of an irrevocable trust) to the trustee of a new trust with different provisions, often to correct drafting errors or to account for new circumstances.” Utah's decanting statute appears in the Utah Uniform Trust Code, Part 8 - Duties and Power of Trustee, section 75B-2-812.5.

Under this new law, unless the terms of the trust instrument expressly prohibit the trustee from doing so, "the trustee may: (i) distribute part or all of the income or principal to a trust governed by a trust instrument that is separate from the trust instrument of the first trust; or (ii) modify the terms of the trust instrument of the first trust." This assumes that the trustee "has discretion under the terms of a trust instrument to distribute income or principal to, or for the benefit of, a beneficiary of a trust..." and provides twenty days written notice to all of the trust beneficiaries. The trustee must also determine whether distribution or modification is necessary, and the beneficial interests in the trust cannot fundamentally be changed through the decanting.

Various other provisions of Utah Code 75B-2-812.5 restrict a trustee's decanting power (1) if a beneficiary can name themself as trustee or remove and replace the trustee with a related or subordinate party, (2) if the trustee is also a beneficiary, or (3) to protect the integrity of certain types of trusts or gifts to trusts. While decanting a trust was arguably within the trustee's common law power in Utah prior to Utah Code 75B-2-812.5, this statute serves as a valuable clarification and authorization of the decanting power.

Pros and Cons of Utah's Joint Tenancy Presumption Amendments

In the estate planning context, the most important implication of owning property in joint tenancy with another person is the fact that the surviving joint tenant will automatically inherit the interest of the first deceased tenant, irrespective of any last will or trust agreement of the first deceased tenant. For this reason, part of the estate planning process is a careful evaluation of how property is owned and often a change of ownership from joint tenancy to ownership by a trust.

It is very common for spouses to own their personal residence in joint tenancy unless they have completed an estate plan that includes the execution and funding of a trust. Importantly, joint tenancy ownership can be presumed even if the vesting deed for the residence does not specify joint tenancy ownership. For many years in Utah, "an ownership interest in real estate granted to two persons in their own right who are designated as spouses in the granting documents is presumed to be a joint tenancy interest with rights of survivorship..." Utah Code 57-1-5(a)(1)(i).

However, pursuant to H.B. 37 (2024), an ownership interest granted on or after May 1, 2024 to two or more persons in their own right is presumed to be joint tenancy even without the designation as spouses. This will have the benefit of avoiding the need to probate the estate of a first deceased spouse who owns their home or other real estate with the surviving spouse but without any reference to the marriage or joint tenancy on the deed.

On the other hand, this new law could create a problem where business partners take title to an investment property in their individual names without specifying their respective ownership interests in the property. It is unusual for a business partner to be the intended heir of another business partner's assets, but H.B. 37 would create exactly this result if the deed only lists the individuals' names and does not specify that ownership is to be as "tenants in common" or make a similar distinction. The obvious solution is to always specify what kind of tenancy is intended when taking title to real estate, and H.B. 37 makes this even more important for many co-owners of property.

The Utah Uniform Health Care Decisions Act

In a prior post, I discussed the Utah Advance Health Care Directive Act, which established rules for individuals designating an agent to make health care decisions if they become unable to do so and provided instructions to govern medical treatment. Pursuant to S.B. 134 - Health Care Decisions Act Amendments, this act has been repealed effective January 1, 2026 and replaced by the Uniform Law Commission's Uniform Health Care Decisions Act.

According to the Uniform Law Commission, "The [new] Act modernizes and expands on the Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act approved by the [ULC] in 1993." These modernizations include provisions addressing "how health care is delivered, increases in the number of non-traditional familial relationships and living arrangements, the proliferation of the use of electronic documents, [and] the growing use of separate advance directives exclusively for mental health care..."

The new Act does address mental health care issues, and Utah does have a separate form exclusive to mental health care. The new Act does not directly reference Utah Code 26B-5-313 - Declaration for mental health treatment or the accompanying Declaration for Mental Health Treatment form found in Utah Code 26B-5-315, which I discussed in a prior post. The new Act does, however, include a number of provisions addressing multiple directives. When it comes to mental health, the key benefit of a Declaration for Mental Health Treatment when compared with a new Health Care Directive appears to be that a Declaration for Mental Health may not be revoked if the principal is considered incapable of making mental health treatment decisions by two physicians. In contrast, revoking a Health Care Directive is governed by a process referenced in Utah Code 75A-9-114.

As with the Advance Health Care Directive Act, the Health Care Decisions Act provides an optional form to create an advance health care directive. One of the most noticeable differences between the two forms is that the new uniform form contains significantly more opportunity to express health care wishes under various circumstances. However, since a useable version of the new form does not appear to have been published yet, the rollout of the Health Care Decisions Act is only just beginning.

Small Estate Affidavits No Longer Work to Transfer Water Shares

As I discussed in a prior post, most states allow title to certain property to be transferred by sworn affidavit, without the need for any probate court intervention or supervision. Utah is one such state: Utah Code 75-3-1201 provides that thirty days after death, any person in possession of personal property belonging to the decedent may transfer the property to a person claiming to be the successor of the decedent if the successor has signed an affidavit, the value of the entire estate subject to administration does not exceed $100,000, and no probate proceedings have commenced.

Historically, shares of stock in a water company owned by a deceased individual were eligible to be transferred in Utah on the basis of a small estate affidavit. Water shares are different from water rights, which are generally transferred by deed and are appurtenant to the underlying property. Ownership of water rights can often be verified by searching the Utah Division of Water Rights website located here. However, because water rights are generally transferred by deed and because not all deeds are reported to the Water Rights Division, this website does not always have current information. In contrast, shares in a water or irrigation company are generally transferred by a physical stock certificate that represents the owner's interest in the company, and it is the company itself that owns underlying water rights.

Because real property interests such as appurtenant water rights cannot generally be transferred pursuant to a small estate affidavit (for more information, see this prior post), a small estate affidavit is unlikely to be effective for transferring water rights in the name of a decedent. In addition, due to the enactment of H.B. 89 (2025), Water Transfer Amendments, shares of stock in a water company are no longer eligible to be transferred in Utah on the basis of a small estate affidavit. This makes pre-death planning with the assistance of a knowledgeable estate planning attorney all the more important if the goal of probate avoidance in an estate plan is to be achieved.

Petition to Construe a Power of Attorney

In a prior post, I discussed Utah's adoption of the Uniform Power of Attorney Act. The Act is still in place but, pursuant to S.B. 79 passed in 2024, has been recodified and now begins with Utah Code 75A-2-102. In this post, I discuss one of the remedies under the Act, specifically, a Petition to Construe a Power of Attorney.

Utah Code 75A-2-114(8) provides that only a limited category of persons can request that an agent "disclose receipts, disbursements, or transactions conducted on behalf of the principal." In contrast, Utah Code 75A-2-116 allows a broad category of persons to "petition a court to construe a power of attorney or review the agent's conduct and grant appropriate relief."

According to the Uniform Probate Code comments, "The primary purpose of this section is to protect vulnerable or incapacitated principals against financial abuse [by setting forth] broad categories of persons who have standing to petition the court for construction of the power of attorney or review of the agent’s conduct." This section is designed as "a check-and-balance on the narrow scope of [Utah Code 75A-2-114(8)] and provides what, in many circumstances, may be the only means to detect and stop agent abuse of an incapacitated principal."

A Petition to Construe a Power of Attorney can be dismissed upon motion by the principal "unless the court finds that the principal lacks capacity to revoke the agent's authority or the power of attorney." Utah Code 75A-2-116(2). This is designed to protect the self-determination of principals. In addition, at least one court has found that such a petition can be dismissed where the petitioner lacks sufficient interest in the outcome. Williams v. Boggess for Ward, Va.App.2024, 899 S.E.2d 636. Nevertheless, a Petition to Construe a Power of Attorney can be a useful tool to protect vulnerable adults from exploitation.

Obtaining a Court Order Correcting a Death Certificate

In prior posts, I discussed establishing the fact of a birth or death where there is no birth or death certificate as well as changing a sex designation on a registered birth certificate. This post describes the process for obtaining a court order to correct a death certificate. 

UT Admin Code R 436-3-7 permits funeral home directors and family members to amend a death certificate in certain circumstances. The Utah Department of Health and Human Services website provides two different forms for amending a vital record; depending on the information needing to be correct, a court order may be required.

A petition for an order to correct a death certificate can be filed as a probate matter under the authority of the above-cited code section or, more broadly, Utah Code 78B-6-401, permitting "declaratory judgments determining rights, status, and other legal relations..." Individuals whose rights would be impacted by the change in information on the death certificate should be notified.

At the court hearing, which may be held as part of the consent calendar, if no one objects and adequate evidence of the need for the correction of the death certificate is provided, the court will issue the order. The court order should direct the Utah State Vital Records Office to allow a specific person who is related to the decedent to amend the death certificate and specify the information to be replaced and the correct information. This order is then submitted with the Affidavit to Amend a Vital Record by Court Order to the Office of Vital Records and Statistics.

Freezing a Financial Account

Financial institutions are permitted to freeze a customer's account if they believe that the account is at risk of being misappropriated or they suspect unauthorized activity. The institution's policies and customer agreements will discuss this option; for example, Bank of America's Deposit Agreement and Disclosures states, "If at any time we believe that your account may be subject to irregular, unauthorized, fraudulent or illegal activity, we may, in our discretion, freeze some or all of the funds in the account and in other accounts you maintain with us, and/or delay transactions, without any liability to you, until such time as we are able to complete our investigation..."

Financial institutions need to balance various federal and state consumer protection laws designed to protect account holders from wrongfully being denied access to their funds with fraud-prevention laws imposing various reporting requirements and restrictions on permitting illegal activity. Both federal and state laws protect financial institutions from taking affirmative action with respect to an account under certain circumstances. For example, Utah's Financial Exploitation Prevention Act provides states, "If a qualified individual reasonably believes that executing a requested wire transfer will result in financial exploitation, the covered financial institution may (a) delay the wire transfer; and (b) contact [authorities]..." Utah Code 7-26-201(2).

These laws and policies often become relevant in the case of financial accounts owned by elderly or otherwise vulnerable adults, and various laws and policies specifically address such specific situations. See, for example, Utah Code 7-26-301(1). It is not uncommon for an elderly account holder to be in the early stages of dementia or otherwise compromised such that a question arises as to their capacity to properly manage their finances. Such situations can lead to competing claims to an account among family members. Again, quoting Bank of America's Deposit Agreement, "We are not required to make payment from an account to [any] person claiming an interest in any funds in the account [if]... there may be a bona fide dispute between the signers, beneficiaries, payees, or other persons concerning their rights to the account proceeds..."

One tool available to advocates for vulnerable adults is to put financial institutions on notice of a dispute over an account or exploitation of their client. This may be all the bank needs to freeze the account until a proper investigation, settlement agreement, or court order can be obtained.

New Form 990 Upload Requirement for Utah Nonprofits

As I discussed in a previous post, the Utah legislature recently removed the requirement that charitable organizations register with the Division of Consumer Protection in order to legally solicit contributions. At that time, new administrative rules were to be drafted requiring certain charities "to upload their most recent Form 990 as part of the corporation's filing process."

Pursuant to new R152-22-7, charities must begin submitting a PDF of their IRS Form 990 on an annual basis "using the process established by the Division of Corporations and Commercial Code" at the time the charitable organization registers as either a domestic or foreign nonprofit corporation or submits its annual report to the Division of Corporations and Commercial Code.

The new online process established by the Division of Corporations for filing a renewal for a nonprofit corporation now asks whether the corporation is a "charitable organization" as defined in Utah Code 13-22-2 and, if the question is answered affirmatively, asks if an IRS Form 990 filing requirement exists. Unless the corporation is exempt from filing a Form 990, in order to complete the renewal with the Division of Corporations, a copy of the most recent Form 990 must be uploaded.

Changing a Sex Designation on a Registered Birth Certificate

In a prior post from 2022, I discussed Utah Code 26-2-15, which has since been recodified to Utah Code 26B-8-119, pursuant to which a person may petition for a court order establishing the fact, time, and place of a birth for which no registered birth certificate is obtainable. In this manner, a birth certificate could be issued where one previously did not exist. At this time, nearby section 26-2-11 of the Utah Code provided a means for amending an existing birth certificate. Specifically, this statute provided instruction to the registrar that if a name change or sex change had been approved by a court, pursuant to an application form approved by the registrar, the registrar was required to "note the fact of the amendment on the otherwise unaltered original certificate."

Utah Code 26-2-11 was repealed and reenacted in 2023 to create "the procedure a court must follow to grant a petition to amend the sex designation of a birth certificate." Pursuant to this reenacted statute, a court may grant a sex designation change on a birth certificate if, among other things, the petitioner shows by clear and convincing evidence that he or she "has transitioned from the sex designation of the biological sex at birth to the sex sought in the petition [and has] outwardly expressed as the sex sought in the petition in a consistent and uniform manner for at least six months; and... suffers from clinically significant distress or impairment due to the current sex designation on the birth certificate."

Upon receiving such a court order, the petitioner is entitled to receive "a birth certificate that does not indicate which fields were amended..." Utah Code 26-2-11 was recodified in March of 2023 to Utah Code 26B-8-111. This statute was amended earlier this year to require a petitioner for a name or sex designation change to indicate whether they are registered with the Sex and Kidnap Offender Registry and allow the court to consider whether to grant the petition for any who are so registered.

Utah Code 26B, Chapter 8, Part 1 - Vital Statistics contains the law for issuing and modifying birth and death certificates. Section 111 is particularly helpful to individuals who have transitioned from their biological sex at birth as indicated on their original birth certificate.

Donations of Closely-Held Business Interests

As I discussed in a prior post, a donation of closely-held stock to a charitable organization can be highly tax efficient because (1) the donor receives a deduction for the fair market value of the donated asset, (2) the donor avoids paying tax on the asset's built-in gain, and (3) the charity, being tax-exempt, also avoids paying tax on any gain from the sale of the asset. However, the IRS has historically and in recent years especially challenged the avoidance of tax on the built-in gain under what is known as the "assignment of income" doctrine.

Often, a donation of stock or interest in an LLC occurs shortly before the sale of the business. In these cases, the IRS argues that the donor's right to proceeds from the sale of the donated interests became "fixed" or “practically certain to occur" before the gift was actually made, meaning that the donor would be required to pay tax on the gain built into the interest transferred to the charity.

Whether the donor's right to the proceeds associated with the gifted interests is "fixed" is a facts-and-circumstances test. In Estate of Hoensheid v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2023-34 (2023), the court looked at a donation that occurred shortly before a sale and considered factors including the status of the revisions of transaction documents at the time of the gift, the target company taking actions that presuppose the sale will close, any legal obligation to sell by the donee, and the status of the corporate formalities required to finalize the transaction.

The court in Hoensheid ruled against the taxpayer in a circumstance that was similar to many donation and sale transactions. There are indicators that the IRS is automatically pulling for audit any in-kind gift make within two weeks of the liquidity event, although legally there is still no bright-line rule on timing in an assignment-of-income case. Anyone contemplating a donation of a closely-held business interest before selling their business should obtain experienced legal counsel before undertaking such a transaction.

Introduction to the Utah Advance Health Care Directive Act

Author's Note: I help maintain certain Thomson Reuters Practical Law resources for trusts and estates in Utah, including their Advance Health Care Directive (UT) resource. I recently helped update this resource as a result of Utah's S.B. 79 - Estate Planning Recodification, which, among other things, changed many Utah statutory references. This post draws upon this Thomson Reuters resource.

An important part of any person's estate plan is the designation of an agent to make health care decisions for the person if they cease to be able to make or communicate their own decisions. Similarly, it is important to provide instructions to govern medical treatment, including wishes for the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining care. Utah's Advance Health Care Directive Act provides a statutory form that accomplishes both of these objectives and which is found in Utah Code 75A-3-303.

The statutory form in Utah is optional but highly recommended because it is presumed to be valid if executed properly and is the form that third-party health care providers are generally familiar with. The statutory form consists of two parts: Part I - Health Care Power of Attorney, wherein a health care agent may (but is not required to be) designated, and Part II - Living Will, wherein the individual’s end-of-life treatment preferences are expressed.

In addition to providing for the naming of an agent, Part I sets forth the authority the agent should have. In a guardianship proceeding, the nomination of a guardian often is critical; accordingly, the person executing the health care directive should usually initial "yes" in Part I of the health care directive form to designate the same person named as agent to serve as their guardian. In my practice, this guardian nomination is typically the most important section of the health care directive form.

A person's wishes for end-of-life is often the most important section of the form for agents, successor agents, and family members. Persons executing a health care directive should express their wishes for end-of-life care on Part II of the form but also discuss these wishes with their agents and family and also include any additional language that may clarify their wishes. By executing an Advance Health Care Directive and carefully considering each of the sections of the form, individuals can significantly reduce the possibility for conflict and uncertainty when they reach the end stages of their lives.

The Jointly-Owned "Convenience Account"

One common source of controversy in end-of-life planning and estate and trust administration is the existence of a financial account owned jointly by the decedent/contributor and another person who is not the sole heir of the decedent's estate. As I discussed in a previous post, the key features of most joint accounts is that any party to the account may unilaterally withdraw the funds in their entirety and the surviving joint account holder will automatically be entitled to retain the remaining amounts in the account upon the death of the other owner. The last will or trust agreement of the decedent would have no impact on this result.

After the death of the owner of the contributor of the funds, the other heirs of the estate may attempt to recoup funds that automatically passed by operation of law by the surviving joint owner. However, this is a difficult and expensive process because the funds will no longer be in the name of the contributor, and the law exonerates the bank if it pays out the funds to the surviving joint owner. In litigation to recover the funds from the surviving joint owner, the court will presume that all aspects of the joint account arrangement are valid and the other heirs will need to overcome this presumption by clear and convincing evidence.

Theories for overcoming the presumption that ownership passes to the surviving joint owner include fraud, mistake, incapacity, or other infirmity. Another theory for overcoming the survivorship presumption on a joint account is that the account was intended as a mere "convenience account," or an account established to assist with handling money and affairs but with no intent to pass ownership of the remaining funds.

Factors that could potentially suggest the existence of a convenience account include the decedent being the sole source of the funds and retaining possession of checkbooks, debit cards, etc.; the failure of the surviving joint owner to assert ownership during the lifetime of the contributor; or the acknowledgment of the non-contributor of the intent to use the funds to provide for the contributor's needs. However, factors that suggest that the account was not set up jointly solely for convenience, but rather with intent to pass ownership, include the account balance being far in excess of what the contributor needed, the contributor relinquishing possession of checkbook, or the non-contributor asserting ownership during lifetime. See McCullough v. Wasserback, 518 P.2d 691 (1974).

In order to avoid disputes, individuals should carefully consider all of the legal implications of creating a new joint account or adding a family member to an existing account as a joint owner. If the account is intended to be a mere convenience account, it should be documented as such along with the contributor's other estate planning documents.

Old Expired Entities Can Now Be Reinstated in Utah

On March 13, 2024, Utah's governor signed S.B. 14 - Corporate Dissolution Amendments, which is effective beginning this month. Previously, a business entity that had been administratively dissolved for failing to file an annual report only had two years from dissolution in which to file for retroactive reinstatement. Under this new law, entities can apply for reinstatement "under the corporation's same corporate name at any time after the effective date of dissolution," if the corporate name is still available.

This new law is a significant improvement to Utah's corporate regime. Previously, "[t]he termination of the status of an entity as a corporation (for state law purposes) could possibly cause a change in the treatment of the entity for federal income tax purposes, unless the state law action can be treated as irrelevant or is subsequently reversed retroactively." Streng, "IRS Treatment of the State Law Dissolution (and Revitalization) of a Corporation", Real Estate Journal (BNA). In other words, there was at least a question of whether an inadvertent entity dissolution could create irreparable federal income tax problems in Utah simply because retroactive reinstatement after two years was unavailable.

Under the new law, a dissolved entity retains its corporate name for five years and can reinstate under that same name within that five-year timeframe. If the prior name is unavailable, it appears that the same entity can still retroactively reinstate, just under a new name. S.B. 14 will remove legal uncertainty created by inadvertent administrative dissolution of Utah entities.

Utah Repeals Charitable Solicitation Registration Requirement

As I discussed in a previous post, many states require charitable organizations that solicit money to register before fundraising. Until this month, Utah was included in this group of states where registration was required. However, on March 13, 2024, Utah's Governor signed H.B. 43, Charitable Solicitations Act Amendments, which among other things, "removes a requirement that charitable organizations register with the Division of Consumer Protection."

This new law is effective May 1, 2024, but as of March 29, 2024, the Utah Division of Consumer Protection stopped accepting charitable solicitation registration applications. The new law will require certain charities "to upload their most recent Form 990 as part of the corporation's filing process," which will be the subject of forthcoming administrative rules. This requirement begins on January 1, 2025 and will generally require domestic and foreign nonprofit corporations to "file an unredacted copy of the charitable organization's most recent IRS Form 990, 990-EZ, 990-N, or 990-PF." Note that most 990 forms are currently available on the IRS's Tax Exempt Organization Search website.

Even small Utah charities may still be required to register to legally solicit donations in other states, depending on how they fundraise. While these laws change frequently, this chart by Lowenstein Sandler is a good starting point for researching the requirements that apply to charities across the 50 states. For assistance in understanding the application of these laws, please contact knowledgable legal counsel.

Filing a BOIR Report for New LLC

The Corporate Transparency Act ("CTA") is now active law, and most new entities formed in 2024 must file a Beneficial Ownership Information Report ("BOIR") identifying their beneficial owners with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network ("FinCEN") within 90 days of formation. Entities existing prior to 2024 have until the end of this year to file. For an introduction to the Corporate Transparency Act, see my prior post.

FinCEN provides detailed step-by-step instructions for filing a BOIR here, and this post will supplement those instructions. To file a BOIR, visit www.FinCEN.gov and click "File Your Report Now." This will take you to the E-Filing System through which the BOIR is filed. Bank Secrecy Act reporting is also mentioned on this page, but BOIR filing is commenced by clicking "Get Started" where BOIR is referenced. The next page provides two primary options, which are to file a PDF BOIR or an Online BOIR; this post will describe the online alternative.

After agreeing to only use the system for authorized purposes, select the "Type of filing," which for purposes of this post will be an "Initial report" for a newly-formed entity. No login or account is needed in order to file a BOIR. The process is straight-forward and involves simply selecting the correct options and entering the information, first about the reporting company itself and then the applicant(s) and beneficial owner(s).

The next screen asks and then confirms whether the entity is an existing reporting company, meaning one that was already in existence as of January 1, 2024. Entities existing prior to 2024 need not report any company applicant information, but entities formed in 2024 need to provide company applicant information. Applicant information (name, birthdate, address, etc.) can either be provided directly, or if the applicant has previously obtained a FinCEN ID, the ID number can be entered instead. Requiring a FinCEN ID of company applicants and beneficial owners significantly simplifies initial reporting and the requirement to update reports if information about an applicant or owner changes.

After inputting information for all applicants, or their FinCEN IDs, the next page is where beneficial owner information (name, birthdate, address, etc.) is inputted. Note that a clear image of appropriate picture identification must be uploaded for both applicant(s) and beneficial owner(s) if a FinCEN ID is not provided. After the beneficial owner information is inputted, the final page is where certification of the information is provided and the report submitted.

The following page allows the filer to download the transcript of the BOIR, which is critical so that the data submitted can be kept on file by the company for when, among other things, information about the entity changes. Filing and updating BOIRs is an important new requirement for most U.S. entities.

Introduction to the Corporate Transparency Act

On January 1, 2024, the new federal Corporate Transparency Act will require the vast majority of small U.S. entities to start filing an online report with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) and report beneficial ownership. Existing entities will have until January 1, 2025 to file this report, but entities formed in the new year will need to file within 30 days of formation. Reports with FinCEN are already required for, among other things, foreign accounts, which I discussed in a previous post. However, the CTA is a big deal and represents a complete upheaval of current entity formation and maintenance practice. A number of exceptions to the reporting requirements apply, but generally only include large entities or entities that are otherwise subject to an existing regulatory regime, such as financial institutions. In other words, it is small entities that are being targeted by the CTA, and ultimate individual beneficial ownership is the primary reporting objective.

The reporting requirement is imposed upon the "reporting company" itself, which is any entity formed by filing a document with a state agency. This means that most trusts will not themselves be reporting companies but will likely have complex requirements to provide information about various trust participants if the trust owns a reporting company interest. "Senior officers" of a reporting company are liable for penalties of up to $500 for each day that the violation continues, imprisonment for up to two years, and/or a fine of up to $10,000. Beneficial owners of a reporting company that provide false information or refuse to provide information to the reporting company can also face penalties. A beneficial owner is any individual who exercises "substantial control" over a reporting company or owns or controls at least 25 percent of the ownership interests of the reporting company.

The key pieces of information required of beneficial owners include full legal name, date of birth, physical home address (P.O. Boxes are not allowed), and a copy of the individual's driver's license or passport. If any of this information changes, the reporting company must file a change report. Much of the burden of reporting and keeping track of a beneficial owner's change of information appears to be relieved in large part if the beneficial owner obtains his or her own FinCEN identification number and the reporting company reports that number. Given the detailed personal information that is required to be disclosed and the substantial penalties for noncompliance, we will be hearing much more about the CTA at the start of the new year.